I would pass without question if it's in the condition you're describing. Revolvers out of time can either be a simple fix, or end up costing more than it's worth. IMHO $600+ for a working model 36 is too rich for my blood. If they're asking $600 now there is slim to no chance to get it for $400. that's way too deep a cut into the profit margin.

 

If the timing doesn't work correctly empty it won't loaded either. There's another member listing parts for one for less than $220. I wouldn't pay very much for one that needs fixing (maybe $100) & I can repair my own. Around here in good shape that would sell for around $450. You do the math.

 

Not sure where you are located, but here (SE Fl) a nice would sell for 400-450.

 

I would also pass on any revolver with the timing off as well. Just wait around for one that works correctly.

 

Cylinder timing can be a tricky problem. Its not a simple fix and if its an older Smith you are going to have to hand cut the ratchet and star and the hand. Id pass on the gun unless your really good at working on them. the gun has been treated badly if the timing is that bad.

 

Is the gun actually stamped Mod 36 in the yoke? Got a serial #?

W/o knowing the vintage of the gun, it's impossible to value it. $600 is a steal for a Baby J w/3" barrel.

They're crazy if they won't deal on a gun that's not timing properly.

You're describing a "carry up" problem on the timing. It will work better loaded because the inertia from the weight of the cartridges helps the cyl roll forward better to lock up. But irrelevant, it should be fixed! About as simple a fix as there is on revolvers. Everybody wants to throw new parts in it, An absolute waste of money.

The timing can be fixed in about 10 minutes if you want to work on it and I'll send you specific instructions if you're considering getting it.