Smith And Wesson Forums banner

651-1 J frame .22 magnum

2 reading
22K views 14 replies 6 participants last post by  jamo002  
#1 ·
Have any of you owned or fired one of these little J frame 22 Magnum jewels?

I went to a local gun show two weeks ago to look at a model 48 to add to my collection but fell in love with this four-inch barrel J frame instead. It just felt right in my hand.

What prompted all of this is that I have never had a 22 Magnum. The new superlight J frame 22 Magnum snubby at 11 ounces raised my interest in the subject of 22 magnums in general. In a fit of total stupidity I visited a local gun shop with my friend Al. Al likes to buy new guns at retail. Amazingly, they had the Ruger single six convertible with the 22RF and 22 Magnum cylinder on sale for $400. Then, showing my gross stupidity, I bought one. Thank god they took the Ruger on trade against the Smith 651 and, I feel I got my origonal $400 back in trade.

This Ruger revolver has been for sale for years and I guess the concept of getting two cylinders is what keeps it alive. I had two complaints:

1. Compared to any Smith & Wesson it simply inspired no pride of ownership.
2. It was a real pain having to use the ejector rod to remove the spent brass. I have two reproduction SSA's in 45 colt that I shoot in cowboy competition. With the cowboy loads, you simply open the loading gate, rotate the cylinder, and the brass falls out of the gun. With the Ruger 22 Magnum the brass was expanded tight in the cylinder and the ejector rod was required.

So now I have a gorgeous little 651-1 and I guess I better go get that nice big K frame model 48 to put in my collection before it disappears.
 
#3 ·
I had one & it was a very accurate, well-made gun but prefered the M650 (fixed sight, 3" heavy barrel). I have a M351PD & it's a very good 'all-around' revolver too. A .22 magnum can do almost everything well, w/ solid bullets it is a good small game round, w/ hollow-points a good coyote & javelina gun and out-penetrates a .357. I think you'll be happy w/ yours.
 
#4 ·
I've been craving that M351 PD all along IniunBro. Problem is, here in Atlanta there scarce as parakeet teeth. I'm about to go down to the gun shop tomorrow and just pay full price for one.

There is only one other gun that puts out a good flame like a 22 Magnum and that's an 1896 Mauser with 7.62 Russian sub gun ammo. That's a little hot to shoot the basement.
 
#5 ·
jamo002 said:
I've been craving that M351 PD all along IniunBro. Problem is, here in Atlanta there scarce as parakeet teeth. I'm about to go down to the gun shop tomorrow and just pay full price for one.

There is only one other gun that puts out a good flame like a 22 Magnum and that's an 1896 Mauser with 7.62 Russian sub gun ammo. That's a little hot to shoot the basement.
Shooting one when it's almost dark is sort of like being inside a lightening bolt :shock: . I hate to rub your nose in it but I had 2 of them & only paid $350 each. One I traded to a friend, the other I still have. The factory grips didn't fit me but w/ aftermarket grips they are pretty accurate if you know how to hold a snubbie. .22 magnums are pretty popular here. If you buy one, even @ full price, I think you'll like it.
 
#6 ·
I like the .22 Magnum fine, but I do prefer a bit longer barrel. But I'm happy to hear that you got such a nice one - the J-frame is a great platform for the caliber.

But speaking of pride of ownership, here's my little Bearcat .22 Magnum (thanks to Mr. Bowen), a lot like a J-frame:

Image
 
#10 ·
OK Injunbro,

You are responsible for my actions Friday night and Saturday afternoon. I found a 351PD with the pretty wood stocks on line Friday night for $636+tax, right here in Atlanta so, in a drunkin fit I used our credit card and bought it for pick up Saturday afternoon. When I got there they wouldn't reverse the credit card transaction and let me pay cash from my triple super secret emergency fund.

Get the picture? Now my wife is going to know I bought another gun! I will give her your name to explain my actions.

By the way, this thing really does weigh 11 oz. empty and 12.2 oz. loaded. its not even trying to pull my pants down but it sure is going to need a trigger job.

How about it guy's and gal's. I never did a T job on a post-lock S&W. Do I use the same spring kit as for a pre-lock J frame? I have one J frame kit on hand so I guess I could just start by swapping the main spring and see is she fires off the .22 Mag rim fire's.

On my lightened up center-fires I use Federal primers only.

I'm gona be in big trouble when the credit card bill comes in and right now, I really don't care.
 
#11 ·
Oh well, I've been accused of influencing plenty of worse things!:lol: I can still run pretty fast for an old crippled up halfbreed & your wife will have to hunt through a lot of mountains.;) On the other hand if I'm going to get killed anyway I may as well buy myself a new gun to enjoy in the meantime. njgapjgj I'll tell my wife I had to because you told your wife and...
I did trim a coil from the mainspring on one of my 351PD's (the one adopted by my wife) & it still goes bang... .22 mag's do require a little harder firing pin hit to fire dependably than a .22lr. I never needed to do more than that to make it shoot decently so I left it alone after that.
In the meantime enjoy your new lightweight as if there's no tomorrow, when you wife catches on there may not be. :lol: I figure that's why God made me twice as big as my wife... it gives me a chance of survival. ;)
 
#15 ·
I've had a lot of handguns in the last 40 or so years but I got my first 22 Magnum to months ago and since then I've fallen in love with this caliber.

In my basement I have a chronograph in front of a police quality backstop (that's supposed to take 44 Magnum) and I got a say the flame that comes out of a 22 Magnum handgun is just plain fun.

It's like Larry the Cable Guy says. "I don't care who you are, this is fun!"