[Poohgyrr]

OK.

I had to pull out a new avatar, and that had me looking at my revolvers.

So, if we could only have two (3) S&W wheelguns, then which ones (of what we have) would we keep? At least until we think of another one we also want to keep...

PS: Well, OK. we can include one (1) that we don't already own. :ymhug:

PPS: Ok again. This is for two only, but as that doesn't always work, others can be mentioned as "runners up". Kinda like beauty contests. :ymapplause:

Here are all three of my only two (3) guns that would work for me as I shop about town or go camping (no bears): a Centennial type and short barreled K & N frames:

A 640-1 and friends. Gotta have at least one J frame, and the Airweight 642 almost took this spot in my list:

A 3 1/2" .357 eight shooter. I like autos, but figure that if the world spinning 'round and 'round is good enough for Mother Nature, then my only two guns should also.

Besides, if 8 rounds of .45 are good, then 8 rounds of .357 have to be at least as good. My other choice(s) is also .357 and that is good. A lot of goodness here. :mrgreen:

I call this the Minigun of Goodness:

What about you guys, here is another chance at this timeless thread....

 

[Guest]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

4" 627 Standard and a 5" 686P.

 

[Bob K]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

Kind of silly, but...... M-66-1 2 1/2" and M36 2".....both for protection. THAT is the most important reason for owning a gun!!!! Bob

 

[Leighton]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

My model 28 4" and my 640ND. Second runner up would be my 64 4" and an 18 4". The 18 I don't have but want badly.

 

[Ralph G]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

Great lookin guns John !!

I`ve seen those guns of yours before and they still look great !!

 

[fat tom]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

K-22 and a 4" Python,if I could only keep two REVOLVERS. If only Smiths,then sub a 4" pre-29 for the Colt.
f.t.

 

[Guest]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

My mod 17 and mod 686. Between a .22 and a .357 should be able to do anything normally needed to be done with a handgun, (but still need a rifle and a shotgun).

 

[woodsltc]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

Not my "highest valued" but the two S&W's I shoot the most ..... K-22 (pre- 18) & M-586 (no dash).

I use both as "woods walkers" and all-round users, so if I had to choose only two S&W's these would be the ones.

Don

 

[bmcgilvray]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

The favorite two.

Model 10 Heavy Barrel

Model 17

 

[Deek]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

This is really hard and I will probably change my mind as soon as this posts, but my two favorites (right this second) are my 25-2

and my model 60 pro

Ask me again tomorrow and I will tell you something different! :mrgreen:

 

[Jim]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

I would have a hard time picking two. For me this M&P would be one of them.

 

[jimg11]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

:ymhug: This thread has caused me to change my mind many times but the 22/32 is a very important gun for me.

And I have always been partial to the 3" J Frame such as this Bodyguard Model 49.

Maybe I will change my mind before everyone reads this but that is my answer and I will stick to it today anyway.

 

[carl418_resigned]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

I've thought about this for over a week and still can't come up with the same answer two days in a row.. :-\

What a cruel, cruel question!! :lol:

 

[Poohgyrr]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

I've thought about this for over a week and still can't come up with the same answer two days in a row.. :-\ What a cruel, cruel question!! :lol:

:ymdevil:

I have the same problem, and that is why I fudged the question by allowing "runners up" pistols to be included. Leaving out the 4" M19 and 2" M10 was not easy. Dittos for the 642, like I already mentioned..

But, that just means I can pick a new pair whenever I want. Kind of like having an extra Christmas.

 

[revorg]

Re: New look, so a new "Only two S&W revolvers" thread..

The two I use the most I guess.
4" 29-2
6" five screw K-22

Runners up would be my 4" 629 P&R and my 4" M34 kit gun.

and a whole bunch of also rans...

 

[Leighton]

Since its been changed to three we have, I'll have to go with, this is hard, my 14, 17, and for EDC my 60-4 3". That way everything is covered I would really need a revolver for.

 

[crebralfix]

Easy:

S&W Model 27 "new" Registered Magnum

S&W K18 with 4" barrel (22 Long Rifle)

My third gun would be another eight shot M27 with 3.5" barrel.

 

[bmcgilvray]

If we get a runner up then I'll add a .32-20 Hand Ejector.

 

[Poohgyrr]

klgasilBRVO

Yup, not only do we get a runner up, but we can have as many Levers as we want!

 

[gearchecker]

My 6" Model 14-3 K-38 Masterpiece (by far my favorite) and
my 4" Model 629-4.
My 4" Model 66-3 is going to be my back-up gun.
If I never carry it, does it really count?