I've said this before so many times folks might think I own stock in them, but I don't. Sticky Holsters are a thin grippy textured holster where one size fits many guns. I have two sizes (forget what they are 6L might be one?) and they will successfully and comfortably hold anything from a 2" snubby up to a full size 1911. I have a 1076 in one now, and that same holster will carry my 66-1 w/2 3/4" barrel or a 6906 or a Sig P229. And they don't move all day long.
Certainly worth a try for $30 bucks or so. Good luck!
Depends on the application. I have used molded Tagua and Galco for CC I have a Galco open top that a leather worker trimmed the security strap off of. With tensioning adjustments and for secure open carry I have a tub full of gimme's. They all work.